DBSync for MSSQL & MySQL: Fast, Reliable Data Replication

DBSync for MSSQL & MySQL: Setup Guide & Best PracticesData synchronization between Microsoft SQL Server (MSSQL) and MySQL is a common requirement for hybrid environments, migrations, reporting, and high-availability setups. This guide walks through planning, installation, configuration, and best practices for DBSync solutions that synchronize data between MSSQL and MySQL. It covers architecture choices, schema mapping, change capture, scheduling, error handling, performance tuning, security, and monitoring.

---

1. Overview and when to use DBSync between MSSQL and MySQL

Database synchronization tools (collectively “DBSync” in this article) help keep two database systems consistent by copying data and schema changes in one or both directions. Use synchronization when you need:

• Real-time or near-real-time replication for reporting, analytics, or caching.
• Gradual migration from MSSQL to MySQL (or vice versa) while keeping systems in sync.
• Data consolidation from multiple MSSQL instances into one MySQL data warehouse.
• Heterogeneous high-availability or geo-distributed deployments.

Pros of using a DBSync tool:

• Handles heterogeneity (different datatypes, SQL dialects).
• Built-in conflict resolution and change data capture (CDC).
• Scheduling, retry, and logging capabilities.

Consider full migration instead of continuous sync if you can tolerate downtime and want to simplify architecture.

---

2. Architecture patterns

Pick an architecture that matches latency, consistency, and complexity requirements:

• Uni-directional replication (MSSQL → MySQL or MySQL → MSSQL): simpler, suitable for migrations or reporting.
• Bi-directional (conflict-prone): requires conflict detection/resolution and careful primary key strategy.
• Hub-and-spoke: central hub database syncs with multiple spokes.
• Staging-based ETL: extract from source into staging, transform and load to target (good for batch workloads).

Factors to decide:

• Latency requirements (real-time vs. batch).
• Write frequency at each side (single-writer simplifies conflicts).
• Network reliability and bandwidth.
• Schema drift management (how often schema changes).

---

3. Planning: schema mapping and datatype compatibility

MSSQL and MySQL have different datatypes and SQL variants. Before syncing, create a mapping plan:

Common datatype mappings:

• MSSQL VARCHAR / NVARCHAR → MySQL VARCHAR / TEXT (ensure length/charset)
• MSSQL DATETIME / DATETIME2 → MySQL DATETIME / TIMESTAMP (watch timezone behavior)
• MSSQL UNIQUEIDENTIFIER (GUID) → CHAR(36) / BINARY(16) in MySQL
• MSSQL DECIMAL(p,s) → MySQL DECIMAL(p,s) (preserve precision)
• MSSQL BIT → MySQL TINYINT(1)

Key considerations:

• Character sets and collations: align encodings (UTF-8 recommended).
• Auto-increment / identity columns: decide which side owns ID generation (use GUIDs or application-generated keys to avoid collisions in bi-directional setups).
• Nullability differences and default values.
• Indexes, constraints, and foreign keys: some sync tools don’t replicate constraints; recreate them on the target if needed.
• Stored procedures, triggers, and views: often must be rewritten for target SQL dialect.

Create a mapping document for each table: source column → target column, datatype conversion, default value policy, and any transformation rules.

---

4. Change Data Capture (CDC) and synchronization methods

Common CDC and sync methods:

• Log-based CDC: reads database transaction logs (MSSQL transaction log, MySQL binlog) — lower overhead and near real-time.
• Trigger-based CDC: triggers write change events to a shadow table — simpler but more overhead and risk of cascading failures.
• Timestamp-based polling: polls rows by a last_modified timestamp column — easy but limited by clock drift and resolution.
• Full-table refresh: drop and reload data — simple for rare syncs but not efficient for large/active datasets.

Recommendations:

• Prefer log-based CDC for production real-time sync (e.g., using SQL Server CDC or third-party log readers).
• Use timestamp polling for small tables or where CDC isn’t available.
• Avoid trigger-based CDC for very high write loads; use it only when other CDC options are impossible.

---

5. Installation and connectivity

Prerequisites:

• Network connectivity between MSSQL and MySQL servers (or between servers and the DBSync host).
• Proper database user accounts with least privilege necessary (read on source, write on target).
• Open firewall ports (MSSQL default 1433; MySQL default 3306) or use secure tunnels/VPN.

Steps (typical):

1. Install DBSync software or agent on a server with stable network access to both DBs.
2. Create DB users:
   • MSSQL: a user with SELECT, and rights for CDC/log reading if required.
   • MySQL: a user with INSERT/UPDATE/DELETE, and schema modification rights if the tool creates tables or indexes.
3. Test connectivity with simple client tools (sqlcmd, mysql client).
4. Configure source and target endpoints in the DBSync UI or config files.
5. Define tables and columns to sync; apply the mapping plan.
6. Configure CDC method (log-based preferred) and initial snapshot settings.

Initial snapshot:

• For existing data, most tools take an initial snapshot. Ensure a maintenance window or use online snapshot techniques to avoid long locks. Validate row counts and checksums after snapshot.

---

6. Conflict handling and bi-directional sync

If writes occur on both sides, design conflict strategies:

• Last-writer-wins (timestamp-based): simplest but can lose updates.
• Source-of-truth priority: one database wins on conflict.
• Field-level merges: only merge non-conflicting fields.
• Custom conflict-resolution hooks in the DBSync tool.

Best practices:

• If possible, avoid bi-directional writes—use single-writer or segregate write sets by table.
• Employ monotonic timestamps or vector clocks for robust conflict detection if bi-directional sync is necessary.
• Log and alert all conflicts for manual review when automatic resolution may be unsafe.

---

7. Scheduling, batching, and throughput tuning

Tuning parameters to control performance:

• Batch size: larger batches reduce overhead but increase memory and collision risk.
• Parallel workers: increase throughput but ensure target can handle concurrent writes.
• Transaction size: keep transactions reasonably sized to avoid long locks and log growth.
• Network and compression: enable compression if supported for WAN links.

For heavy write volumes:

• Use parallel table partitioning or sharded sync workers.
• Use bulk loaders on the target (LOAD DATA INFILE for MySQL) for initial mass loads.
• Monitor and tune MSSQL transaction log retention if using log-based CDC.

---

8. Error handling, retries, and idempotency

Design sync jobs to be idempotent and resilient:

• Use unique keys or upsert (INSERT … ON DUPLICATE KEY UPDATE / MERGE) semantics.
• Implement exponential backoff for transient failures.
• Persist change positions (log sequence number, binlog file/offset) so retry resumes without reprocessing.
• Keep detailed logs and dead-letter queues for rows that repeatedly fail validation or violate constraints.

---

9. Security and compliance

• Use TLS for connections to both MSSQL and MySQL.
• Use least-privilege database accounts.
• Store credentials securely (vaults, environment variables, or encrypted config).
• Audit and log data access and changes for compliance.
• Mask or exclude sensitive columns if regulations forbid replicating certain PII.

---

10. Monitoring and alerting

Monitor:

• Lag between source and target (row/transaction lag).
• Error rates and retry counts.
• Throughput metrics (rows/sec, bytes/sec).
• Resource usage on DBSync host, source, and target (CPU, IO, memory).
• Transaction log or binlog consumption.

Alert on:

• Lag exceeding SLA thresholds.
• Repeated failures for same table/row.
• Disk or log growth nearing capacity.

Use dashboards (Prometheus/Grafana, ELK) and built-in DBSync metrics.

---

11. Testing and validation

Before production:

• Run end-to-end tests on staging with realistic data volumes.
• Validate schema mapping and datatype conversion with a representative sample.
• Verify idempotency and conflict resolution by simulating concurrent updates.
• Use checksums and row counts to verify data parity:
  • Per-table row count comparison.
  • Per-partition checksum (e.g., MySQL CHECKSUM TABLE or custom hash).
• Test failover and recovery procedures, ensuring CDC offsets restore correctly.

---

12. Maintenance and schema evolution

For schema changes:

• Version your schema and apply migrations in a controlled manner.
• For backward-incompatible changes, use a rolling strategy: add new columns, populate, switch writers, then remove old columns.
• Update mapping configurations in the DBSync tool before applying production schema changes.
• Re-run snapshots only when necessary (large snapshots can be disruptive).

Regular maintenance:

• Rotate credentials periodically.
• Vacuum/optimize target tables as needed (MySQL OPTIMIZE TABLE, index rebuilds).
• Purge or archive old logs and snapshot artifacts.

---

13. Common pitfalls and troubleshooting tips

Pitfalls:

• Charset mismatches causing garbled text—use UTF-8 end-to-end.
• Identity/auto-increment collisions in bi-directional sync—use GUIDs or centralized ID allocation.
• Long-running transactions during snapshot causing log growth—use online snapshot tools.
• Unhandled schema changes breaking pipelines—coordinate schema changes with sync configuration updates.

Troubleshooting steps:

• Check DBSync tool logs for exact SQL errors.
• Confirm positions in transaction logs/binlogs to ensure progress.
• Reconcile counts and checksums to find missing or transformed rows.
• Test connectivity and credentials if sync stalls at connection steps.

---

14. Example minimal configuration (conceptual)

This conceptual example shows key settings you’ll find in most DBSync tools:

• Source: mssql://user:password@host:1433/Database
• Target: mysql://user:password@host:3306/Database
• CDC method: log-based (transaction log / binlog)
• Initial snapshot: enabled (consistent snapshot option)
• Conflict resolution: source-of-truth = MSSQL
• Batch size: 500 rows
• Parallel workers: 4
• Retry policy: exponential backoff, 5 max attempts
• Monitoring: push metrics to Prometheus

---

15. Conclusion and checklist

Quick checklist before going live:

• [ ] Mapping document complete for all tables.
• [ ] Secure, least-privilege accounts created.
• [ ] CDC method configured and tested.
• [ ] Initial snapshot validated (row counts/checksums).
• [ ] Monitoring and alerting in place.
• [ ] Conflict strategy set for bi-directional cases.
• [ ] Backups and rollback plan ready.

Following these guidelines will help you set up a reliable DBSync between MSSQL and MySQL that balances performance, consistency, and maintainability.