Common Pitfalls When Moving from MSSQL to PostgreSQL (MsSqlToPostgres)

Automating MsSqlToPostgres: Scripts, Tools, and WorkflowsMigrating a database from Microsoft SQL Server (MSSQL) to PostgreSQL can unlock benefits such as lower licensing costs, advanced extensibility, and strong open-source community support. Automating the migration — rather than performing it manually — reduces downtime, minimizes human errors, and makes repeatable migrations feasible across environments (development, staging, production). This article covers planning, common challenges, key tools, scripting approaches, sample workflows, validation strategies, and operational considerations to help you automate an MsSqlToPostgres migration successfully.

---

Why Automate MsSqlToPostgres?

Automating your migration provides several concrete advantages:

• Repeatability: Run identical migrations across environments.
• Speed: Automation shortens cutover windows and testing cycles.
• Consistency: Eliminates human error in repetitive tasks.
• Auditability: Scripts and pipelines give traceable steps for compliance.

---

Pre-migration Planning

Successful automation starts with planning.

Key steps:

• Inventory all database objects (tables, views, stored procedures, functions, triggers, jobs).
• Identify incompatible features (T-SQL specifics, SQL Server system functions, CLR objects, and proprietary data types like SQL_VARIANT).
• Decide data transfer strategy (full dump, incremental replication, change data capture).
• Set performance targets and downtime constraints.
• Prepare staging and testing environments that mirror production.

---

Common Compatibility Challenges

• Data types: MSSQL types (e.g., DATETIME2, SMALLMONEY, UNIQUEIDENTIFIER) map to PostgreSQL types but sometimes need precision adjustments (e.g., DATETIME2 -> TIMESTAMP).
• Identity/serial columns: MSSQL IDENTITY vs PostgreSQL SEQUENCE or SERIAL/GENERATED.
• T-SQL procedural code: Stored procedures, functions, and control-of-flow constructs must be rewritten in PL/pgSQL or translated using tools.
• Transactions and isolation levels: Behavior differences may affect concurrency.
• SQL dialects and functions: Built-in functions and string/date handling can differ.
• Constraints, computed columns, and indexed views: Need careful treatment and re-implementation in PostgreSQL.
• Collations and case sensitivity differences.

---

Tools for Automating MsSqlToPostgres

There are several tools to help automate schema conversion, data migration, and ongoing replication. Choose based on scale, budget, and feature needs.

• pgloader

  • Opensource tool designed to load data from MSSQL (via ODBC) to PostgreSQL. It can transform data types and run in batch mode.
  • Strengths: high-speed bulk loads, flexible mappings, repeatable runs.

• AWS DMS / Azure Database Migration Service

  • Cloud vendor services supporting heterogeneous migrations with CDC for minimal downtime.
  • Strengths: managed service, integrates with cloud ecosystems.

• ora2pg / other converters

  • While originally for Oracle, some tools support translating SQL Server to PostgreSQL with configurable rules.

• Babelfish for Aurora PostgreSQL

  • If using AWS Aurora, Babelfish provides T-SQL compatibility layer, easing stored procedure and app-level changes.

• Commercial tools (ESF Database Migration Toolkit, DBConvert, EnterpriseDB Migration Toolkit)

  • Often include GUI, advanced mapping, and support contracts.

• Custom ETL scripts (Python, Go, PowerShell)

  • For bespoke requirements, write scripts using libraries (pyodbc, sqlalchemy, psycopg2) to extract, transform, and load.

---

Scripting Approaches

Automation typically combines schema conversion, data transfer, and post-migration verification.

Example components:

1. Schema extraction script
   • Use SQL Server’s INFORMATION_SCHEMA or sys.* views to dump DDL metadata.
2. Schema translation
   • Apply mapping rules (data types, default expressions, constraints).
   • Use template-based generators (Jinja2) to produce PostgreSQL DDL.
3. Data pipeline
   • For bulk loads: export to CSV and use COPY in PostgreSQL, or use pgloader for direct ETL.
   • For CDC: set up SQL Server CDC or transactional replication and stream changes to Postgres (via Debezium or DMS).
4. Orchestration
   • Use CI/CD tools (GitHub Actions, GitLab CI, Jenkins) or workflow engines (Airflow, Prefect) to run steps, handle retries, and manage secrets.
5. Idempotency
   • Design scripts to be safely re-runnable (check for existence before create, use transactional steps).

Sample skeleton (Python + Bash):

# extract schema python scripts/extract_schema.py --server mssql --db prod --out schema.json # translate schema python scripts/translate_schema.py --in schema.json --out postgres_ddl.sql # apply schema psql $PG_CONN -f postgres_ddl.sql # load data (parallel CSV + COPY) python scripts/export_data.py --out-dir /tmp/csvs for f in /tmp/csvs/*.csv; do   psql $PG_CONN -c "py ${f%.csv} FROM '$f' WITH CSV HEADER" done # run post-migration checks python scripts/verify_counts.py 

---

Example Workflow for Minimal Downtime Migration

1. Initial bulk load
   • Extract a consistent snapshot (backup/restore or export) and import into Postgres.
2. Continuous replication
   • Enable CDC on MSSQL and stream changes to Postgres with Debezium + Kafka or AWS DMS.
3. Dual-write or read-only cutover testing
   • Run application reads against Postgres or employ feature flags for dual-write.
4. Final cutover
   • Pause writes to source, apply remaining CDC events, perform final verification, switch application connections.
5. Rollback plan
   • Keep source writable until confident; have DNS/connection rollback steps and backup snapshots.

---

Validation and Testing

• Row counts and checksums: Compare table row counts and hashed checksums (e.g., md5 of concatenated columns) to detect drift.
• Referential integrity: Verify foreign keys and constraints are enforced equivalently.
• Query performance: Benchmark critical queries; add indexes or rewrite them as needed.
• Application tests: Run full integration and user-acceptance tests.
• Schema drift detection: Monitor for unexpected changes during migration window.

Example checksum SQL (Postgres) for a table:

SELECT md5(string_agg(t::text, ',' ORDER BY id)) FROM (SELECT * FROM table_name) s(t); 

---

Operational Considerations

• Monitoring: Track replication lag, error rates, and database health metrics.
• Backups: Ensure backup and restore procedures are established for Postgres.
• Security: Migrate roles, map permissions, and handle secrets securely.
• Performance tuning: Adjust autovacuum, work_mem, shared_buffers; analyze query plans.
• Training: Developers and DBAs should be familiar with Postgres tooling and internals.

---

Troubleshooting Common Issues

• Data type overflow or precision loss: Add conversions and validation in ETL scripts.
• Long-running migrations: Use parallelism, chunking, and table partitioning to speed up.
• Stored procedure translation: Prioritize by frequency and complexity; consider Babelfish if available.
• Referential integrity violations during load: Disable constraints during bulk load then validate and re-enable.

---

Checklist (Quick)

• Inventory objects and incompatibilities
• Choose tools (pgloader, DMS, Debezium, custom scripts)
• Create idempotent, tested scripts
• Implement CDC for minimal downtime
• Validate via counts/checksums and app tests
• Plan monitoring, backups, and rollback

---

Automating MsSqlToPostgres is about combining the right tools with robust scripting, thorough testing, and operational readiness. With careful planning and the workflows described above, you can reduce downtime, ensure data integrity, and make migrations repeatable and auditable.